“A learned, lively, and witty review of the history of historical writing… A deeply insightful analysis of the never-ending challenge that historians face in getting their story right.” – Richard R. Beeman, John Welsh Centennial Professor of History Emeritus, University of Pennsylvania

“I cannot imagine a reader of this book who will not learn from it and be provoked to a new level of thoughtfulness by it.” – Michael Zuckerman, University of Pennsylvania

“Students and general readers will find no more engaging guide to the value and distinctiveness of what historians do.” – Daniel K. Richter, University of Pennsylvania